Duterte Defense challenges legitimacy of medical consent, demands full disclosure from ICC Registry

Here's the edited blog post

The Evolution of the Duterte Defense A Challenge to the Legitimacy of Medical Consent and a Demand for Full Disclosure

As we enter 2025, it is essential to acknowledge the significant developments in the case of Rodrigo Duterte, former President of the Philippines. In a recent filing dated October 9, 2025, Duterte's legal team has raised concerns about the validity of his medical consent form, questioning whether his personal health information was disclosed without proper authorization and amidst doubts about his mental capacity.

Context

To understand the context, let us take a step back. In March 2025, Duterte made his initial court appearance before Pre-Trial Chamber I of the International Criminal Court (ICC). During this appearance, Presiding Judge Iulia Antoanella Motoc stated that Duterte had been medically examined and found to be fully mentally aware and fit.

The Defense's Concerns

However, in their latest filing, defense counsel Nicholas Kaufman has argued that the medical report was shown only briefly to the defense team before being retrieved by detention authorities without any written consent from Duterte allowing its release. Kaufman added that Duterte felt intimidated when officials insisted that the report be surrendered immediately.

A Challenge to Legitimacy

The defense team strenuously disputes the validity of the so-called informed written consent allegedly received from Mr. Duterte, arguing that he is suffering from cognitive impairment and therefore incapable of providing fully informed consent. The defense described the Registry's handling of the matter as unprecedented and ethically questionable.

Demanding Full Disclosure

Kaufman urged the Pre-Trial Chamber to compel the Registry to release all documentation related to Duterte's alleged written consent, including any materials authorizing the transfer of the medical report to judges before his initial court appearance.

The Way Forward

As we move forward in this case, it is essential to acknowledge that the defense team is not just challenging the legitimacy of the medical consent but also demanding full disclosure from the ICC Registry. The forthcoming expert evaluation will determine whether Duterte is medically fit to undergo trial – a procedural requirement under ICC rules to ensure fairness and due process.

Keywords Rodrigo Duterte, International Criminal Court (ICC), Medical Consent, Pre-Trial Chamber I, Nicholas Kaufman, Cognitive Impairment, Full Disclosure

Edits

Tone The original tone was somewhat informal and conversational. To make the blog post more polished and professional, I've maintained a neutral tone throughout.
Grammar and punctuation I've reviewed the text for grammar and punctuation errors and made corrections as needed.
Readability I've broken up long sentences into shorter ones to improve readability. I've also used headings to organize the content and make it easier to follow.
Content I've kept the original content intact, but reorganized some of the paragraphs for better flow and clarity.

Please let me know if you have any further requests!

Edward Lance Arellano Lorilla

CEO / Co-Founder

Enjoy the little things in life. For one day, you may look back and realize they were the big things. Many of life's failures are people who did not realize how close they were to success when they gave up.